The Descendants Reviews

Our Review

Near-perfect comedy-drama from Clooney and co

Nick Pearson, MovieFix
If a filmmaker can create a scene that reflects a brutally sobering reality, it's a sign of true talent. Same goes if they can make a moment of side-splitting hilarity. In one particular scene in The Descendants, writer-director Alexander Payne manages both.

In Payne's fourth film, George Clooney plays Matt King, a Hawaii lawyer whose wife is severely injured in a boat accident. As he prepares to take her off life support, he is told by his troublesome older daughter Alex (Shailene Woodley) that his wife has been having an affair.

Payne's earlier films Election and Sideways also feature lead characters who are unfaithful to their partners, and they pay the consequences. Since the cheating wife in The Descendants spends the entire film in a coma, the repercussions simply reverberate around her family. King struggles to know how to feel about his wife's infidelity as he tells his friends and family about her impending death.

It's a deeply insightful look at a family in crisis, balancing moments of heavy emotions with that of sharp, often hysterically funny humour. Much of the comic relief comes courtesy of Alex's friend Sid (Nick Krause), a goofy surfer kid unaware of his own stupidity.

Clooney is the only household name in the film, but he is simply leading a stellar cast of practically unknowns. Woodley is marvellous as his difficult daughter, and Robert Forster is his seething best as an angry, grieving father-in-law.

The scenery is spectacular and the mostly Hawaiian music is well chosen. In all, the film is near-perfect — funny without being tacky, emotional without being sentimental.

Your Reviews

Diann Colman
Diann Colman
Utterly boring, slow and a waste of the money it cost to go and see it. Pure CRAP.
sookybear
sookybear
very disappointing. I was expecting sooo much more from this, but instead got a rather unrealistic reaction from Clooney's character to a dreadful situation. I agree the daughter stole the show.
Sarah
Sarah
Loved this film. It was a thoughtful, observant and funny movie. I enjoyed watching all the family 'drama' and relationships play out. A movie that stays in your mind long after you leave the cinema.
bri
bri
it started of saaah boring! infact so boring that me and my friends left the cinema, but now im going to see it again, tonight. because you know what, its one of those movies you would regret walking out of, even know it was boring.. its intresting. it's really intresting, i cant wait to find out what happens!
Robyn
Robyn
Thought the cinematography was great. You (the viewer) felt very much as thought you were in your own neighbourhood. George was very believable, but still George does not do a hell a lot of acting, he is probably there for the eye candy. I agree the older daughter stole the show, she was great hope she get a new comers award. I can't say that I thought it was a comedy, I thought it was very sad most of the time and frustrating, story kinda well told. Would I recommend it, I would say wait until it comes on Fox or watch it on a plane flight. No hurry!!!
Very enjoyable movie. Loved the acting by George Clooney and the actor playing the elder daughter.
Desley
Desley
So good to know I'm not the only one disappointed with this film. Absolutely agree with Mark!
Charlie
Charlie
great movie i would for sure watch it again if i could :)
margot
margot
Gave it half a star for the acting of the two girls.movie was.utter rubbish. Boring slow..very disappointing like a lot of movies these days
Hayley
Hayley
I went and saw this movie today with a friend who really wanted to watch it. I was mildly interested in seeing it. While it wasn't the worst movie I've ever seen, it wasn't the best either. There were a few parts which made us giggle a bit, but the narrative felt very slow and as though they'd stretched a small storyline into an hour-and-a-half movie. The premise was nice and I thought it was going to be a fairly good movie but I was a bit let down. I also wonder if living in Hawaii means that you have to wear an awful hibiscus/Hawaiian themed shirt all the time, because there were a lot of those shirts...
Mark
Mark
Well, I'm not sure if I was sabotaged by all the hype, and I am usually a fan of George Clooney, but yes, underwhelmed sums it up nicely. Very slow to the point of tedium. George at his unconvincing worst, I then the actor who played Alex, the older daughter was the show stealer and second place goes to Elizabeth (yes, sorry, the one in the coma.) Even the location shots grew tiresome, perhaps because the whole weight of the movie rested on them. If George gets the big gong for this (lack of) effort then I'll know the Academy Awards are about as fair dinkum as a Gillard promise.
grant
grant
time i will never get back wasted on this ordinary film
Really
Really
Bad, just bad
Tom
Tom
Not a bad film, but certainly not a great one either. It was beautifully shot, Clooney and the girl playing his older daughter were very good. The other characters were leaden caricatures - the stoner boyfriend was particularly annoying. The main stinker was the script. An unappealing situation offered no scope for development which left me feeling flat as the credits rolled.
matthew
matthew
the descendants mixes comedy and drama and it blends very well. George clooney gives his best screen performance that is sure to get him the best actor nod in a months time
Fi
Fi
I was caught up in the multiple levels of conflict that are just below the surface of any family as they were portrayed in this film. Clooney was stunning in his powerlessness disconnect of his place in the family. The Descendants was so much more than a modern tale of life. It conveyed the complexities of history, the environment, progress and that old chest nut-greed in a thought provoking and at times funny representation of the human condition.
Steve
Steve
I'd prefer not seeing movies like this for the simple reason I find them miserable and depressing. Although commendable on many counts- well written, good acting etc. it's crushing to the heart. I particularly liked the reference to the first peoples and the way that subject was worked in the story. It was a profound and interesting.
msgoldenhair
msgoldenhair
very ordinary so wait for it to come out on dvd
timeout
timeout
this was a movie worth seeing. enjoyed the drama and the funny moments. Any movie that allows you to escape for a few hours from everyday rigors of life, is entertainment. judging by the packed audience we shared that viewing, seems whole lot of other folk did too.
Kerry Spencer
Kerry Spencer
Anyone that likes this movie has to be bored with life. Clooney isn't the best actor and never will be! As far as as a comedy....not a funny movie, small things amuse small minds for those who thought it was. Don't waste your money!!
expect nothing
expect nothing
One star and one word for this film - Underwhelming.
An advertisement for tourism...
An advertisement for tourism...
After seeing The Descendantslast night, I do not undrestand the hype & "oscar buzz" surrounding George Clooneys performance. It is by no means a poor movie but I found much of the acting to be almost silly in parts with many scenes drawn out & with only a handful being really meaningful. The music played throughout the entire film becomes tiresome & although the scenes of Hawaii are stunning, it literally accounts for half the movie! Its as if the local tourism board has a stake in the film. Anyway, not a bad film all-round but it really could have been much better.
The decendents
The decendents
I was never a great fan of george Clooney as I saw him more as a 'pretty face' than an decent actor.But I've changed my mind now. I was very impressed with him in his new role. i would like to see him with more roles that give him the oppertunity to express some real emotion, not simple wise cracks. The movie was a wonderful expression of a family in crises.
Cyncical
Cyncical
Well, my guess is that amost everyone that has seen or is going to see this movie is in love wih George Clooney. Serves them right. The movie is boring, tedious and and a non event. I am not a fan of George Clooney as I think he is highly overated and this movie proves my point.
The Descendants, Its great to see George Clooney in a different role.
very good!
Clarechiosso
Clarechiosso
Well what a boring & depressingly low movie this was! The scenery was bland, the music dull & someone really should tell Clooney he's too old to have a 10yr old. As a nurse the last thing I need is to watch a typical american dysfunctional family watch mum die. I'd rather watch paint dry. Give it a miss unless its raining & need something to do
Tonie
Tonie
This film is unique and as refreshing as a cool breeze on a warm balmy evening. Set in Hawaii, in what is normally a relaxed urban sprawl of natural luxury, a family is plunged into turmoil when mum Elizabeth, is comatosed as a result of a boating accident. In the wake of this incident, Dad Matt, and his young daughters, have to deal with issues they would not normally have been confronted with had the tragedy not disturbed their ideal existence. Don't be put off by this film's patriotic title "The Descendants" and by George Clooney's previous roles as brutish and cruel characters. Although the story revolves around Dad (Matt King), the movie is matriarchal in that it illustrates a culture and attitude that successfully merges business with family lifestyle, life with death, so neutralizing polarities as most typical western cultures eg. America (tangled up in blue (the new white) and black), have not resolved to achieve. In Hawaii there is no heaven or hell, only paradise. Life on earth was meant to be easy. This family deal with their emotions in a functional humane manner. One can not help but empathize and completely comprehend the depth of feelings these people are having to deal with. This film is about Matt King, a wealthy landowner with property inherited from a royal matriarchal generation. George Clooney portrays fatherhood completely competently and naturally illustrating how in Hawaiian culture, women are not only needed, but wanted, as opposed to western culture eg. America, where women don't feel needed or wanted. In patriarchal cultures, men (unless they are rich) as well as women, struggle to achieve. This is a cathartic film.
Ashley Carroll
Ashley Carroll
If you want to see a bad movie this is it. What was george thinking when the script was offered.? The acting wasn't convincing....a waste of money.
Kelly spencer
Kelly spencer
George must have been desperate for a pay cheque.If you need to bore yourself to death it's a must see.!!!
Near-perfect boredom
Near-perfect boredom
Look, maybe I just wasn't in the angst-ridden, moral dilemma-as-drama mood but I found this film really tedious. First of all, it's no comedy - I think I heard the odd uncomfortable giggle in the audience but that would be about it. It's yet another film about cuckoldry - any chance we could get past this Hollywood obsession? It's such a lousy plot-point and really done to death. I mean the guy is estranged from his wife and she has an affair. OK, and... is that it? We don't really care because Clooney's character is unlikeable, as are his sassy daughters and, it would seem, his comatose wife. It warms up eventually I guess with some reasonable character development and good performances from the young girls but compared with the outstanding Sideways (which is why I went to see it) it was a dud and certainly the only time I've been bored with George Clooney in the lead...
Troy Campbell
Troy Campbell
Sure to earn George Clooney a Best Actor nod at the Oscars (he’s already bagged a Golden Globe nom), this life-affirming flick from Sideways and All About Schmidt writer-director Alexander Payne is more of the filmmaker’s trademark ‘serious comedy’. Despite an otherwise depressing tale at its core – Clooney’s wife is in a coma, his two misbehaving daughters aren’t letting up, his extended family is pushing him to sell land that will make them rich, and, to top it all off, he then finds out his wife was being unfaithful to him – Payne’s script, and the quality cast, possess impeccable comic timing. Clooney has perfected his craft over the last few years and here delivers another bold performance; his nuanced and complex character remains achingly relatable and eminently watchable. When the film explores larger themes of Hawaiian culture and ancestral ties to land it gains worthiness to be sure, however loses a portion of the intimateness built up with Clooney and co; making me wonder if Payne should’ve stuck exclusively with the dysfunctional and highly interesting family on show.

Add a review

My Rating
Name
Movie Buzz
Last:
24 hours
7 days
The most anticipated movies on MovieFix
    Biggest Movers
    What is Movie Buzz?
    What is Movie Buzz?
    MovieBuzz rates which movies are trending within the MovieFIX community.
    Movie Buzz Ratings overview
    You can choose if you "Want to see" or are "Not Interested" in seeing the movie on the Homepage trailer player, or in the Movie Information page. After 20 votes, we tally these scores and create a percentage of how many people "Want to see" that movie.
    Movie Buzz Voting overview
    We then take these scores and display the highest percentages in MovieBuzz. MovieBuzz only features movies from their trailer release to two weeks after they have released in cinemas. You can see the rankings on a 24 hour or a 7 day basis (use the radio buttons near the title to switch views).
    'Like' TheFIX on Facebook!Get your daily hit of celebrity, movies, TV and music news and join the conversation. 'Like' TheFIX on Facebook.
    Get MovieFIX on your mobile now!On the bus, at the beach, wherever — get the latest movie times, news and reviews on your mobile now. It's easy!